This is the first time in my life that I've really stood outside of the church and found myself looking in. What I see is what appears to be a fairly exclusionary club where the members have their own coded language and peculiar way of doing things (yes, I said "peculiar" and not "particular"). It's certainly not inviting.
To be around church people one must be conversant in "Christianese." Christianese is a language, yes, but it's also a way of being. I wonder how many people would continue to speak Christianese if they realized how off-putting it is to non-believers and the unchurched or people like me who have stepped outside the church. Assuming, of course, that Christians don't wish to be exclusionary.
I ran into an old friend, a former friend, really. No, that's not right either, it was someone I knew in the context of church. She told me about a hard thing that was happening in her life and I could feel tears welling up in my eyes. I felt such compassion for her. When I told her how sorry I was, she said that she wasn't sorry, that she was unworthy of God's goodness and would willingly suffer whatever came her way, that she wouldn't stop praising the Lord! Her smile was so brittle I wouldn't have been surprised to see her face break into a million tiny pieces.
There was a pause. She said, "He bled for me, Katy. He bled for me." (a Christianese reference to Jesus on the cross)
My eyebrows went up.
I said, "Well, I can certainly see that you're doing your best to be strong." She responded, "It's God in me. Praise God that he's working in me. Everything is owed to Jesus. I'm just going to keep praising Him, Katy. Don't admire me, admire Jesus!"
I blinked.
I mean, I wasn't admiring her at all. I was simply stating what I perceived to be true that she was trying to be strong.
There was nothing in that exchange that felt authentic to me. Instead of seeing active faith, I saw desperate adherence to Christianese. It felt for all the world like she was striving to be admirable, like she was putting her faith on display for me. All I can say is that I perceived nothing of God in it. She struck me as being desperately and willfully lonely.
Before I could walk away she said, "Are you spending time in the word, Katy? How's your walk?" I felt my mouth gape open then shut again. How many times have I heard those words coming from Christian church leaders? How many times have I uttered them myself in my past church life? What do they even MEAN?! I was struck by how condescending those questions sounded, how insincere, how very distant and off-putting.
Not too long ago, I tried to explain my new faith to someone I once considered a dear friend. I barely got out two sentences before he leaped to his feet and left abruptly.
I watched him go and felt sad for a moment. He was someone whose kindness I'd once felt drawn to but it suddenly seemed terribly inauthentic, which is funny because authenticity is something I've heard him speak about numerous times. Well, I guess in a way he was being authentic. He was authenticity disinterested in knowing me outside of the church it seems.
I asked myself WWJD (for those of you who aren't conversant in Christianese, that's an acronym for "What would Jesus do?") and the answer that came to me was simply NOT THAT. He would not have jumped up and nearly upset the table with the quickness of his leaving. He would not have shut the metaphorical door, leaving a "members only" sign wagging on the doorknob in front of me.
More and more lately I am meeting people like me who have stepped away from the church, people who are deeply spiritual but don't feel comfortable in the church (again, for those not conversant in Christianese, "the church" is synonymous with Christians who define themselves as "God's people" and not a reference to a building). Instead, they feel like they want no part in an exclusionary club where everyone begins to look and speak the same. They want no part of the judgment. They don't want to be asked rote questions like, "Are you spending time in the word?" (Ah, "word" means "bible" and the bible is a book that is the literal, infallible word of God, in Christianese.)
I once wrote a blog called The Empty Church and that's really what I see when I close my eyes and envision the church. I envision a place full of lonely echoes, a people who have become inbred and weak.
I think it's time to lay down the Christianese, to shake it off and take a walk out in the wide world, learn to speak the language of the unchurched. Follow the advice of Saint Francis of Assisi who said, "Preach Christ at all times, if necessary use words." I'm absolutely certain that he was not admonishing us to speak in Christianese. He was admonishing us to love authentically.
©Just Kate, April 2010
Enjoy this blog? Receive alerts when new blogs are posted. Just click on either the "Follow" or "Subscribe" button to the right.
To be around church people one must be conversant in "Christianese." Christianese is a language, yes, but it's also a way of being. I wonder how many people would continue to speak Christianese if they realized how off-putting it is to non-believers and the unchurched or people like me who have stepped outside the church. Assuming, of course, that Christians don't wish to be exclusionary.
I ran into an old friend, a former friend, really. No, that's not right either, it was someone I knew in the context of church. She told me about a hard thing that was happening in her life and I could feel tears welling up in my eyes. I felt such compassion for her. When I told her how sorry I was, she said that she wasn't sorry, that she was unworthy of God's goodness and would willingly suffer whatever came her way, that she wouldn't stop praising the Lord! Her smile was so brittle I wouldn't have been surprised to see her face break into a million tiny pieces.
There was a pause. She said, "He bled for me, Katy. He bled for me." (a Christianese reference to Jesus on the cross)
My eyebrows went up.
I said, "Well, I can certainly see that you're doing your best to be strong." She responded, "It's God in me. Praise God that he's working in me. Everything is owed to Jesus. I'm just going to keep praising Him, Katy. Don't admire me, admire Jesus!"
I blinked.
I mean, I wasn't admiring her at all. I was simply stating what I perceived to be true that she was trying to be strong.
There was nothing in that exchange that felt authentic to me. Instead of seeing active faith, I saw desperate adherence to Christianese. It felt for all the world like she was striving to be admirable, like she was putting her faith on display for me. All I can say is that I perceived nothing of God in it. She struck me as being desperately and willfully lonely.
Before I could walk away she said, "Are you spending time in the word, Katy? How's your walk?" I felt my mouth gape open then shut again. How many times have I heard those words coming from Christian church leaders? How many times have I uttered them myself in my past church life? What do they even MEAN?! I was struck by how condescending those questions sounded, how insincere, how very distant and off-putting.
Not too long ago, I tried to explain my new faith to someone I once considered a dear friend. I barely got out two sentences before he leaped to his feet and left abruptly.
I watched him go and felt sad for a moment. He was someone whose kindness I'd once felt drawn to but it suddenly seemed terribly inauthentic, which is funny because authenticity is something I've heard him speak about numerous times. Well, I guess in a way he was being authentic. He was authenticity disinterested in knowing me outside of the church it seems.
I asked myself WWJD (for those of you who aren't conversant in Christianese, that's an acronym for "What would Jesus do?") and the answer that came to me was simply NOT THAT. He would not have jumped up and nearly upset the table with the quickness of his leaving. He would not have shut the metaphorical door, leaving a "members only" sign wagging on the doorknob in front of me.
More and more lately I am meeting people like me who have stepped away from the church, people who are deeply spiritual but don't feel comfortable in the church (again, for those not conversant in Christianese, "the church" is synonymous with Christians who define themselves as "God's people" and not a reference to a building). Instead, they feel like they want no part in an exclusionary club where everyone begins to look and speak the same. They want no part of the judgment. They don't want to be asked rote questions like, "Are you spending time in the word?" (Ah, "word" means "bible" and the bible is a book that is the literal, infallible word of God, in Christianese.)
I once wrote a blog called The Empty Church and that's really what I see when I close my eyes and envision the church. I envision a place full of lonely echoes, a people who have become inbred and weak.
I think it's time to lay down the Christianese, to shake it off and take a walk out in the wide world, learn to speak the language of the unchurched. Follow the advice of Saint Francis of Assisi who said, "Preach Christ at all times, if necessary use words." I'm absolutely certain that he was not admonishing us to speak in Christianese. He was admonishing us to love authentically.
©Just Kate, April 2010
Enjoy this blog? Receive alerts when new blogs are posted. Just click on either the "Follow" or "Subscribe" button to the right.
30comments:
Post a Comment
Secondly: we've talked about this a lot. I've been exactly where you are, and I even remember when I first started to look back at the culture of the churched from the outside. I recall feeling a sense of despondency, and of frustration: how could I communicate what I'd learned with friends who were still on the inside? (And there are some there still)
The answer that it took me so long to figure out was: there are those with whom I'll never be able to connect ever again.
Once you're on the outside you're seen as a backslider, with nothing of real value to say. "Oh" they'll object "but you're wrong. Of course I value you. Jesus does, and so do I" And they'll be sincere, but that sincerity has the context of the culture. There are conditions. Every word you say MUST match up with they believe the Bible says. Anything outside of that is just worldly, an ultimately sinful.
The culture props itself up by its own bootstraps, is self-fulfilling, self-referencing and brooks no honest discussion. (I can hear the howls of protest already.) With some of the adherents you can't break through. I know. I've tried.
It's such a wide world outside of those doors. I found it even more fascinating when I discovered that God isn't limited to the churched; and that His form is found in people from the most unlikely realms of society. And that one doesn't need to be a member of anything for that visible stamp of God's multitude of charactistics to be clear.
Yes, we have talked about this at length but it's a subject I just can't leave. I'm begging people to THINK. Unfortunately, someone invariably gets angry about it, which is sad. We should be able to talk about this without people getting upset, especially if we're committed to being authentic, which is the word du jour in Christianity, albeit I'm not sure what Christians really MEAN when they say it.
I'm a little behind you in my evolution as a Christian. This is the first time I've written on this subject without wanting to pull my words back, without butterflies in my stomach.
You use the word "culture" and I wish I'd included it in my definition of "Christianese" instead of saying "a way of being," because culture is what I'm really talking about here. I don't think most Christians realize that they've alienated society with their exclusivity.
There are a few church folks that fall outside of this norm. I think of my friend Jay in particular. He consistently blows me away with his honesty and willingness to examine the church. His kindness and love are extraordinary. I can count on him to hear my heart. If more church-Christians behaved like that, there would be true revival. Unfortunately, I can't see it happening.
I feel closer to truth than I ever did inside the church. I feel like someone's been standing with their boot on my neck for a very long time and I've finally managed to throw them off and stand. I'm a little bit angry about the way I allowed myself to be manipulated, about how I kowtowed to church leadership. I was indoctrinated, taught not to think. The foundation was set when I was very young and over the years it was built up and reinforced by my immersion in church culture. Thankfully, I was able to get away from it without being angry at God.
There *IS* a wide world outside of church doors and it's populated by spiritual people of such amazing depth. Many of them are people who have been burned by the institution of church. Many are people who won't compromise their individuality, won't conform to dress and language codes. I find such authenticity there. Those are the people who draw me.
Thank you for coming back, Duncan! (I still want to know what you said in French the first time)
My mom was a charismatic Catholic and my father called himself an atheist but he wasn't. It was just his way of disengaging from discussions with well-meaning Christians. He was actually a deeply spiritual man, someone who felt God in nature, but he truly despised the church. After a lifetime spent identifying with my mom, I now find myself identifying very strongly with my father.
Anyway, like you, I admire Jesus hugely. I also admire Gandhi, Buddha, Martin Luther King, Jr., and Mother Theresa. I could go on and on. There's a richness of spiritual truth that can be found in so many different people and places. Over and through it all, I see what I consider to be the essence of God: compassion and love.
There's a Latin phrase: Ubi caritas et amor, Deus ibi est. (Where there is charity and love, God is there.) That pretty much encompasses the essence of my faith.
As you know, I am an outsider when it comes to church and its codes. But I have seen true faith in people, and I have also seen people just going through the motions. Not sure why they do that. It is the family they grew up in and they just want to belong? Or it gives them something that makes them feel better than you? No clue.
When it comes to religion and faith, I prefer people who believe in a God who believes in them and in their strength. People who feel responsible for their own and other's happiness instead of just putting it all in the hands of God and pray that he will somehow magically solve everything.
Thanx for your interesting insights, Katers!
Huggs, Ruggers.
When I do have the occasional encounter with a former church "family" member, I am definitely an outsider, a stranger. I Love your thought provoking prose and will enjoy the rest of the afternoon contemplating...Thanks Katy:)
I'm smiling. :)
RUGGERS!!! Wow, it's good to hear from you.
In the blog I meant to say that I know some amazing church-Christians. I think of our mutual friend Jay who just blows me away with how real his faith is and how willing he is to examine it. He's not "doing church by rote." I see him having faith in God and also taking responsibility for his life. If he ever hides behind Christian platitudes, I'm not aware of it. If the church was full of people like him, I think it would be the source of light it was meant to be.
Anyway, you said, "I prefer people who believe in a God who believes in them and in their strength," and I had to stop and read it again, then one more time. I think you said something really important there, Ruggers. When I was in the church I never once thought God believed in me. I was helpless in the face of his will, always listening to hear his voice. I was robbed of my own competency and sense of self. I find myself no longer able to believe in that kind of God. The God I believe in believes in me!!! I'm so glad you said what you did. THANK YOU, RUGGERS!!!!
Huggers back! ;D
I feel everything you wrote, Sarinda. I thought if I kept trying I would find the right church family, the place where I belonged. Eventually, I found a place where I felt that connection and I thought it was real. The thing is, I had to work HARD to keep my place in that family, I had to continually strive to please, to be the person they wanted me to be.
When I left the church, the silence was deafening. I slipped away slowly and heard not a peep. At first, the silence hurt then I realized my leaving wasn't up for discussion anyway. I didn't want them to try to argue me back to church. That being said, I didn't want them to DISAPPEAR either. Maybe in their eyes I'm the one who did the disappearing. It's hard to say.
Anyway, like you, my relationship with God is MINE. It's not open for discussion in the grocery store aisle. I don't have to give an accounting of whether or not I've spent time "in the word" or am "getting right with God." I still bump into people every now and then who say those things to me and that's where the conversation ends. No power trips. No Christianese. I'm not playing that game.
But, you know what, I found my church. If the church is comprised of God's people then I'm in the church every day. I'm in church right now, talking with you. I'm in church when I turn the church upside and shake it with my friend Wolfshades. I'm in church on facebook when people tell their stories and ask for prayers. I'm in church every time I hear about our friend Jo and her daughter Faith and the love that's being poured out to them every day.
This is my church, my family, my home. I'm glad I finally saw it for what it was. It's not an exclusive club at all. The only requirement is caring. :)
Once, long ago in a land called Married Life, my husband and I were invited to dinner with a new co-worker of his. This dinner turned out to be a bible study group. I was open to listening and joining in. So there we sat listening to readings from the bible. Everyone was nodding and praising Him. I asked one question, nothing at all inflamitory, and I was a heathen. WHAT? Because of a question? The room got cold and I began getting preached too. I shut down, instantly. We thanked them for the dinner and got up and left.
We found out later that we were only invited because it was felt we NEEDED to find God. The only thing this person knew about us was that we did not regularly attend church. UGH!
Years later a woamn from work who I had a casual friendship with invited me to go see "The Passion of The Christ" with her. I had already seen it and thanked her for including me but declined. She then informed me that her Pastor had asked the congregation to each find and take someone who needed to find God and be reminded of what He did for us. WHAT? OMG!
I also remember being very little and listening to women in church whispering about who was wearing what and who was seen with whom... blah blah blah... Very Christain like.
My Church is the sun shining on my face as I raise my eyes to watch the maple tree drop it's helicopter like seed pods, it's the wonder I feel when seeing the wind pick them up and twirl them around and around before allowing them to land on the grass. It's the happiness I feel radiating from me as I witness this as being God's work.
=)
* @sarinda
I like what you said about your faith being "personal and private". That's the way it is for me now too. Didn't use to be. We were always taught to accost strangers and brow-beat them with our faith.
The logic of that doesn't make sense. I don't go around telling everyone how much I love my son and daughter and that they need to as well.
Plus, I found that when I stopped trying to grab converts, I realized how many of them - cigarette-smoking, whiskey swilling absolutely fun people - already have His stamp on them. We are all made in His image, not just a select few.
Took me a while to get to that point.
I'd say we worship in the same church. :)
I've experienced so many similar things, and I've been the one out looking for the someone my church leaders told me to find and witness to or bring to bible study, too. :( I was going to say that it's well intentioned but I'm not sure that it is. I fear it's merely blind adherence to the teachings and expectations of church leadership or religion.
I'm afraid that most of what church people do has become "rote." Not too long ago I tried to sit down with a friend from church but the conversation was painful. I didn't want to talk about church or even God for that matter. I just wanted to hang with her. I knew our differences would divide us if we lingered there. But she couldn't seem to stop herself. I felt like I was sitting down with a wind-up doll. She'd been programmed to say what she said. It was all about "surrender," which was the latest hot Christian concept at the time. Something brought up by a pastor of a mega-church, someone like Rick Warren, I would guess.
And, oh, yes, gossip is HUGE in the church. The leadership is especially guilty because they can gossip, gossip, gossip and do it all in the guise of seeking wise counsel or asking people to pray.
Remember, Chickee, Christians aren't perfect they're just forgiven. It's the best excuse in the world for asking people to do as you say and not as you do.
"We were always taught to accost strangers and brow-beat them with our faith.
The logic of that doesn't make sense. I don't go around telling everyone how much I love my son and daughter and that they need to as well."
As you so often do, Wolfshades, you've used the ridiculous to put a fine point on the truth. Well done!
Ahh... Katy, the sad thing is that upon encountering the bible study in disguise as dinner, I was very open to listen and learn but when I took a moment to question I was practically attacked and that shut me down. Completely.
=) No one is perfect, for that I am forever grateful. I just ask that the forgiven remember that fact also. =)
♥ Maybe we should start a church of our own... We'll call it "The Church of the Open Air and Mind", our philosophy will be to listen, learn, share and love. ♥
Hi Ruggers. =) I love what you have said here. I read it a few times and let it sink in. Yes I think I prefer the same people you do. =)
Chickee, I appreciate what you're saying about your willingness to remain open even knowing you were filling a "quota." It makes me sad that they would attack you for asking a sincere question but I'm not surprised. I once shut down a bible study by saying I didn't think homosexuality was a sin. Instead of allowing me my opinion and having a discussion about it, the study simply ENDED. I was shocked. It was yet another lesson I learned about not questioning and not going against the grain.
And you are VERY right in pointing out that grace belongs to all of us. We are ALL children of God. But religion is by its very nature exclusive. Religion says you're out and I'm in unless you convert. It's one of the reasons I truly dislike religion.
I smiled at the idea of having our own church. I've often thought the same thing. Maybe that's what we have here in our friendship and in the other relationships we've built with other like-minded people.
I love you, girl!
I recently commented to some coworkers that the chuch is so busy being "The CHURCH" that it has forgotten the roots it was born from.
How the love of Christ has become such a cold and passionless desert is beyond me.
I feel that there are a few people who are on the right path with Chritianity. My father, grandparents, a few other relatives and Jay S.
It makes me a little sad to think on Christianese for more than a few minutes. Being conversant in it makes me sigh all the more.
One thing I know and am thankful for to Christianity is the love I feel for you, and Jay, and so many others whom I would never had met without this media.
Would this level of connectedness have been possible without a higher power compelling us? I don't know, nor will I ascribe such an attribute where it may not be deserved.
I am thankful for the love, the compassion, the shear joy these relationships bring that I hope never to be without. My eyes are not necessarily on Christ all the time, but I am very happy they have fallen on you and a few others like you.
God bless and keep you and I in an embrace beyaond what we can see.
JC.
Sorry, my computer is down and I am typing this from my BB. I hope the grammar and spelling make sense.
JC - I was just thinking about you and here you are.
My dad used to say that the church was a crutch. I thought he was so deceived but now I agree with him. That's exactly what it is. And I'm not talking about the church Jesus intended to build. That's something entirely different from what the church has become.
Anyway, I have a church but it's rather unconventional. You're part of my church. :) And I believe that the people I met through blogging and held onto - even many that I chose to let go - were put into my life for a reason. I absolutely believe that. I'm grateful for it, too.
God bless you and keep you and make his face to shine on you, my friend. ♥
Ileene, Every time I hear more of your story I feel both sad and joyful. It breaks my heart to hear everything you've been through and yet your life is a testament to the beauty and strength of the human spirit. You have suffered so much and yet you love. It would be easy to pull back from people and just love animals (I *get you* so well, my friend) but you risk people and love them, too.
I started to tell one of my own stories that's very relevant here but I can't do it without hurting people, so I won't tell it. Suffice to say, I feel you, Ileene. I have been hurt by so many people who claimed to "stand in the light," people who wear their faith like badges of honor, people who use Christianese to hide ugliness that's hard to believe.
Yeah, I'll leave it at that. It's not Jesus or the message of the bible that I have a problem with, not at all. It's what the church has become.
I will probably ramble, because as I read this I thought of so much I wanted to say. First, I have always loved that quote by St. Francis! We would do well to heed his advice! I also smiled huge when I read Ruggi's comment about God believing in us. You are so right, Kate...not something you hear from the pulpit very much...but so true, Ruggi! Kate, I'm gonna send you a DVD...it's only about 15 minutes long...the central message is just that...and the first time I watched it, I teared up, because it's a message that isn't proclaimed nearly enough.
The "christianese" angle has always driven me batty! I remember as a young Christian in a Baptist church, listening to people say "brother" this or "sister" that...it just sounded weird to me! Can't I just be "Jay"? "Brother Jay" just felt strange to me...I never adopted! I also quickly learned how weird some of our catch phrases sounded to normal people..."have you been washed in the blood?"...huh??? "Brother, have you been saved?"....ummm, saved from what? Anyway, I could go on...you know what I mean!
I felt sad when I read the account of your friend who was going through a hard time; I was upset with the next scenario as well, the once admired friend who left abruptly over disagreement with your life views. Here is the problem with those two scenarios: All our life, as Christians, we are told that God loves us unconditionally. We speak that truth...and I believe it IS truth...but we rarely act like it is truth. What we act out is that God loves us...but on condition. Meet the conditions, and you can gain his love...his favor. That is why your friend is stubbornly wearing a plastic smile while going through some of life's hardships: she believes it is the only way God will accept her. Isn't that sad. It's why your friend left abruptly...he believes that is how God would treat you because you are not following "the rules". That...as you very well know...is religion. Jesus came to do away with religion, yet all these years later, we still act more like the pharisees than we do Jesus. What would happen if we truly began to realize that God is not waiting for us to earn his love, but rather that he is passionatly pursuing us with his love!
All this being said, I still go to church! As you know, Kate, there really are some really sweet people that go to church. We will never find a perfect church because people are not perfect. But I think it's a good thing to go to church and have a cross section of people at different growth levels and beliefs...it can be aggravating, but it can also be beneficial. Just like you enjoy people of all different viewpoints to participate in your blogs. The only downside, of course, is the judgmentalism that sometimes rears its ugly head within the church context. But, hey...it breeds patience I guess!
Erwin McManus said this, "If we risk entering a community that claims access to God and we find ourselves betrayed in the process, it becomes the fastest way to become a practical atheist. If religion can bring us to God, it can certainly take us from him." I believe you went through that process, maybe your still going through it. But I am glad you seem to be finding your way back to God , back to a true spirituality. I believe in you, my friend.
Jay
Jay, I have been pondering your words. I think you're absolutely right that most of us come to religion looking for a formula - a set of rules - that will assure our salvation. Even though the message of grace is often parroted, I think it's rarely embraced. The church does indeed seem to be filled with pharisees. That's what I see.
It doesn't turn me away from Jesus. I had to walk away from the institution of church to truly find the Jesus I have spent a lifetime reading of.
I do know there are wonderful people in the church. There's YOU, for one. And I know the church will never be perfect but I'm sick and tired of hearing that. The church can and should be better. True reformation is needed.
For me, the biggest turn off with regards to church is the hierarchical structure - the emphasis on the authority of church leadership. Evangelical Christians tend to poo-poo the idea of Catholic priests, confessionals, and the Pope, and yet evangelical Christianity parrots that very structure! Always there is a human "authority" that seeks to stand between an individual and God.
I am so tired of being judged and "told." I no longer respect those who claim to be ordained by God to lead.
Anyway, as always, I love your input. I've had to spend a couple of days thinking about what you said.
I'm not an atheist, Jay, but I can see that the Christian "community" pushes many there. My father claimed to be an atheist b/c he had been so very disillusioned and hurt by the church. I don't believe he really WAS an atheist but claiming he was served as an effective means to shut people up.
I never left God nor did he leave me. I think for the longest time I was lost in the church and now I'm wonderfully found. :) I believe in a God, as Ruggers so wonderfully said, who believes in me. Thank you for seeing my heart, Jay, and for always being willing to think with me. You give me hope for the church and that's no small thing.
Much love, Katy
Love you, Katy!
Your acquaintance from church believes that all of her troubles are being brought unto her from an outside source. Some vengeful father up in the sky is admonishing her for not being up to par – that is, at least, what I get from what you’ve written. It’s so easy to say, “it’s out of my hands,” or, “whatever happens will happen because it’s his plan.” It’s much easier to go through life when you can blame your troubles on God’s will - It takes all of the personal responsibility away.
I must interject: I do believe in something that connects each of us together – some people choose to call that God. I view things a bit differently though and I should clarify where I’m coming from (I will avoid trying to convert anyone ;) ). We all choose each step we take. We may be guided at times, but, even then, the choices we make are based on free will. Sometimes we will encounter circumstances that force a “change” in us. But, at no time are we being punished or rewarded – we are only encountering a present moment that our past choices have led us to.
Now, back to my point. It seems to me, based on my current views, that your friend would rather give away her personal power to change her life and circumstances, and, instead, hold the belief that she’s being punished by factors out of her control. It doesn’t seem like a very empowering/uplifting belief system.
Not too long ago, I tried to explain my new faith to someone I once considered a dear friend. I barely got out two sentences before he leaped to his feet and left abruptly.
I’m sure it’s very difficult to try and explain your new beliefs to past acquaintances from your church. To many Christians, there is only one belief system – well, I’m sure you know that. They have so much invested in it, anything that threatens it will likely be dismissed or ignored. That is a fear-based reaction. Don’t let it discourage you.
I know it couldn’t have been easy to make all of these changes within, and lose many of the people you once associated with. I respect your strength & courage for trusting your heart instead of the words of other men/women.
LOL! I know you know, Jay! I also know that some people don't know, so I was clarifying for the sake of any of those who might be reading, yo! =D
Love you back!
It's great to see you here, my friend! I had to think about what you wrote for awhile. I was trying to figure out if I could adequately articulate what I think my former friend was trying to express when she wouldn't admit to her own pain. I don't think she felt punished or helpless. I think she felt like she was doing the right, Christian thing. There's the whole idea of submitting to God's will while still praying for what one wants. I think she was trying to show her "surrender" or "submission" to God and her lack of fear (aka: faith). She was also making a huge effort to show that she was praising God regardless of the circumstances. It's all so very Christianese and painful. She was simply doing what she has been taught to do. It's why it felt so horribly inauthentic. None of it was REAL. She was playing a role.
I remember so many times in my own life when I reverted to the same Christianese. I simply played a role, did the prescribed thing. I would pray and believe that God could and would answer my prayer, even if it was with a "no," but I was afraid to speak my fear or let myself feel the full power of grief or horror. I think one purpose served by Christianese is the sense of comfort that comes from laying aside one's feelings and sticking to a rote formula.
It's really hard for me to explain my perception of it. It was so ingrained in ME for so long that it came naturally. Even after our daughter was abducted in Papua New Guinea, I was holding myself together with Christianese. I don't know what it might have been like to simply feel what I felt, to let it rip through me. It's something I'm having to learn since I left the church. There are times when things are inexplicable and awful and there's no way around it. We simply have to feel what we feel, get through it. I never feel abandoned by God, but I do feel fear and a myriad of other emotions that I OWN rather than suppress. I don't know if any of that makes sense.
I know when you and I first met, I was very entrenched in the church but at the same time questing hard for truth. I feel closer and closer to that truth all the time, albeit I know that I will NEVER know. :) I'm learning that most of life is a mystery and I think it's meant to be.
Growing up Catholic was like christianese times 10.
I could not reconcile the humanity of the teachings. It was not all supernatural. It was clearly influenced by man. Just the idea of an insecure God that needed us to bow to him, did not sit well with me. Not if he truly unconditionally loves us. He can't have it both ways. I am not cool with that amongst humans, much less a deity.
Just like in that book blog... this is so on the same topic.. I wrote what I squeezed out of it and I presented points like above to everyone in our 'religion' and I was denounced. I was the trouble maker. I was pitied. I could see it in their eyes, their words, their actions. I was kicked out of the club. Considering everyone I knew was in the club, this was really isolating.
It made me reflect on the meaning of it all. I think I have shared this with you before, but I concluded that the reason for the many religions and prophets was to deliver the same message of love, from many sources, delivered in many ways, to get people to get it. That was why that has happened that way.
I figure the goal, whether it is God, or whomever is to get us to not care about supreme power or the ever after, but to care about each other, while we are here.
Focus... on the sharing of love and feeling of love in our life.
Some need threats... fear.... guilt... a feeling of being select... in a club... special... more important... powerful... all kinds of things.
Being in those circles inauthenticity is going to be a very real experience. They need this way, because they don't get it. I hope they do. I hope people like you and me and whomever else can get them to see that church, religion and select cultures do not accomplish the ultimate in love. LIving in love, does.
That should be our target. All else is pale in comparison in human accomplishment. We see that before us. The prophets showed us that what they learned to live was the paramount goal of mankind. We pay way less attention to all other accomplishments. As a whole, this is what people aspire to, and dream of.
I feel that what happens is fear takes a hold of us as not deserving or being good enough to experience such. That effected mans interpretations of the teachings of prophets and caused the confusion in the message.
I so love your writing... your blogs... your thinking..... your heart... your mind... hahaha...
you blushing yet? I know you do NOT like me doing that stuff... but damn... Katy.... why have I missed your blogs? I need to make sure I don't.
You are a real treasure.... :)
Drew
xoxo
I *am* blushing! lol Thank you, Drew.
I absolutely, unequivocally agree with you about God's heart and message being apparent in many faiths with the common message about love and compassion. It's unfortunate that we get caught up in all of the rituals and religion when the message is really so very simply.
I grew up Catholic, too, and my first step away from the church was from Catholicism to evangelical Christianity. My mom and grandma said I would break their hearts and I loved them dearly but it was too important to me to be authentic about my faith to pretend to believe something in order to placate them. They got over it because they loved me.
The step from evangelical Christianity to where I am now was horrifically hard but having made it, I feel free and closer to God.
Post a Comment